Introduction
In last weeks lab we discussed the Dectes Stem borer and its impact on both sunflowers and soybeans. We learned that the Dectes stem borers overwinter inside the base of host plant stems. And that the distribution of the borer throughout the Unites States can be linked to how cold the winter temperatures can be and if the Dectes can survive the winter in certain areas. We know that the super cooling temperature for Dectes is around -15 to -20 degrees C. So in lab we worked to develop an experiment that would test some of the factors that we thought would affect the overwintering success of the Dectes stem borer. As a class we came up with Tunnel Humidity, Stem Size, Chamber size, Snow insulation, Soil presence and Dectes Size as possible field factors that could affect the success of Dectes overwintering.
DiscussionAs a class we decided to test the rate of Dectes survival using stem size as our variable. The hypothesis formed was that a larger stem would create greater insulation and thus the survival rate would be higher for larger stems. We decided to use both sunflower and soybean stems to compare the rate at which they cooled and if their size could contribute to Dectes survival, also included was a control temp taken from outside a plant stem but exposed to the same conditions. From the experiment data which I have given below, you can tell that the control data set was the first to decline in temperature. While the soybean was second and it took slightly longer for the sunflower to cool. From the graph below we can say that our hypothesis was correct, and that the larger stems did take longer to cool. Also, given the control points we can tell that being inside a stem at all helps to reduce how dramatic the temperature drop is. Personally i had anticipated the difference is cooling to be more pronounced.
Cool temperature below 0 degrees C would have little effect on the stem borer, their supercooling point as i stated above is quite colder than 0 degrees C. Unless exposed to 0 degrees C for a very extended period of time, at which point i assume some death would occur. I'm unsure if the stalks being wet would dampen the effect of the cold, but if the experiment were to be repeated with dry stalks we could definitely compare and then we would know! Other sources of error could be thermocouple placement in the stalk, it would be hard to get them all in the center etc.